I didn’t realize I was drifting until my writing started to feel like someone else’s voice wearing my clothes.
Every time I sat down to draft a blog post, I could feel two conflicting instincts pulling me in opposite directions.
One part of me wanted to write freely—unfiltered thoughts, long sentences, ideas not tied to SEO or structure.
The other part? It was already thinking in headlines, keyword clusters, calls to action, and funnel logic. It wasn’t a creative block. It was a creative identity crisis.
At some point in your blogging journey, you’ll probably experience the same split. You’ll question whether your current approach reflects who you really are as a creator—or just what you’ve been conditioned to do by algorithms and advice.
That tension is what this article is about.
You don’t need to choose between art and strategy. But you do need to understand which mode you naturally operate from.
Over the past decade of working with creators—from Substack writers to niche bloggers to brand publishers—I’ve noticed five recurring blogger archetypes. Each one has a different source of creative energy, a different relationship to metrics, and a different path to growth.
Recognizing your dominant type won’t box you in. It’ll help you clarify where your creative power comes from—and how to use it more intentionally.
1. The Storyteller: Driven by emotion, connection, and inner truth
Storytellers write to feel. To process. To connect. Their posts often begin with a memory, a scene, or a moment of transformation.
The best ones make you forget you’re reading a blog—they feel like letters from a friend or a personal monologue that just happens to echo something in your own life.
Storytellers usually thrive on platforms like Substack or Medium, where voice matters more than virality. But in the blogging world, they often struggle when told to “niche down” or “productize their knowledge.” Those demands feel mechanical and soul-numbing.
If this is you, the key isn’t to abandon your emotional lens—it’s to build structure around it. Think of Cheryl Strayed’s “Dear Sugar” column. It was deeply emotional, yes—but it followed a reliable format that made it sustainable.
You can monetize storytelling. But you need to pair it with rituals—publication cadence, post formats, and gentle constraints that protect you from burnout and keep your work flowing.
Brené Brown’s early blog was a good example of storytelling without strategy. As her message matured, her voice didn’t get louder—it got clearer. That’s the art of becoming a more intentional storyteller without diluting the power of your honesty.
2. The Strategist: Obsessed with frameworks, funnels, and scalable systems
Strategists see blogging as a gameboard. Their minds naturally sort ideas into categories, steps, templates, or repeatable processes. Their best content breaks things down, clarifies confusion, and turns abstract goals into action plans.
This type of blogger often excels in business, productivity, finance, or marketing niches. They rarely publish without a content calendar, and their posts are engineered to convert—whether that’s traffic, subscribers, or leads.
The upside? They know exactly how to reverse-engineer results. The downside? They can drift into lifeless content that checks all the boxes but lacks resonance.
If you’re a strategist, your challenge is to keep your content emotionally alive. Inject more of your own voice, values, and story into your frameworks. Your audience may come for the structure—but they’ll stay for the depth.
Creators like Tiago Forte and Marie Poulin have mastered this balance. They offer tools and systems, but you can also feel the clarity and conviction behind their work.
One tip for strategists: occasionally publish something messy. Share what didn’t work. Talk about nuance. Not everything needs a clean five-step process. Vulnerability humanizes the machine.
3. The Teacher: Fueled by curiosity, clarity, and the thrill of insight
Teachers blog to explain things. Their greatest joy comes from breaking a complex concept into something clear and usable.
They’re the ones who dive into rabbit holes for fun, who can spend hours creating diagrams, who always seem to have another tab open.
You’ll often find teacher-bloggers in tech, science, or educational niches—but they show up everywhere. What makes them unique isn’t their topic—it’s their instinct to explain.
Teachers sometimes get stuck in the “knowledge trap”: assuming that if they just explain the facts clearly enough, readers will care. But emotion matters too. So does pacing.
If this is your dominant type, remember: clarity is only half the job. Engagement is the other half. Use storytelling techniques—narrative hooks, personal examples, rhetorical questions—to help your explanations land with more power.
Ali Abdaal is a great example of a teacher who evolved. His early blogs were purely instructive. Over time, he began weaving in personality and storytelling, which expanded his reach far beyond productivity geeks.
And for teacher-bloggers aiming to grow: consider building your own frameworks. Don’t just repeat the research—reframe it through your unique lens. That’s what makes your content memorable.
4. The Curator: Passionate about pattern recognition, taste, and synthesis
Curators don’t always write the most—but they’re constantly consuming, connecting, and sharing.
Their genius lies in seeing trends before others do, in spotting the through-lines between disciplines, and in assembling resources that others can’t stop bookmarking.
Many successful newsletter authors fall into this category. They don’t necessarily need to create original ideas—they create context around ideas. They help readers make sense of the flood.
If this is your strength, lean into formats like “what I’m reading this week,” roundups, annotated links, or trend spotlights. But also—don’t be afraid to insert your own take. Curation becomes valuable when it’s not just a list, but a lens.
Maria Popova’s Brain Pickings (now The Marginalian) is the gold standard of this archetype. It’s curation elevated to philosophy.
Your audience follows you not just for what you collect—but for how you make meaning from it.
If you want to monetize as a curator, focus on depth, not breadth. A paid curation model works best when your lens is so specific, people follow your taste—not your topic.
5. The Builder: Focused on experimentation, tools, and creative momentum
Builders blog through doing. They don’t want to theorize about what might work—they want to try it, tweak it, share the results, and start again. They treat blogging as a sandbox for ideas, a place to test products, projects, or prototypes in public.
Builders often run indie SaaS blogs, side project journals, or “build in public” newsletters. Their strength is honesty and iteration. They attract readers who want to learn from real-world action, not polished theory.
The risk? Inconsistency. Builders can burn bright and fast—but without structure, they burn out.
If this is your mode, build checkpoints into your process: commit to monthly updates, create templates for your project breakdowns, and share lessons learned—not just wins.
Arvid Kahl is a notable example of a builder who turned transparency into trust. His blog charts the messy, real process of entrepreneurship—not just the outcomes.
Builders thrive when they document while building—not just after the fact. Think aloud, publish drafts, and invite feedback. It’s the process that creates the community.
Why knowing your type creates more freedom, not less
These five types aren’t rigid boxes. They’re starting points.
Most bloggers have a dominant type, with traces of others. Some begin as teachers, and evolve into storytellers. Others build hybrid identities—like a strategist with a curator’s eye.
What matters isn’t the label. What matters is the awareness.
When you understand your natural blogging archetype, you stop forcing yourself into shapes that don’t fit. You stop copying formats that drain your energy.
You start designing your workflow, your topics, and even your monetization around your actual strengths.
It also helps explain creative friction. If you’re a storyteller being told to publish SEO-optimized listicles every week, of course you’ll resist. If you’re a strategist trying to emulate a poetic narrative voice, you’ll struggle to hit publish.
There’s nothing wrong with expanding your range. But it should start with your core—not deny it.
And if you feel pulled in two directions? You’re not broken—you’re probably standing on the edge of a creative evolution. That’s when a hybrid identity starts to form. When a teacher becomes a strategist. When a builder finds their storytelling voice.
That’s how blogging becomes less of a performance—and more of a practice.
Finding your true type (and growing from there)
Start by reflecting on your past work. Which blog posts came most easily? Which ones drained you? Which ones felt deeply “you”?
Then, look at who you admire—and why. Not just the topics, but the energy. Do you admire clarity, vulnerability, precision, depth, or experimentation?
Finally, ask your readers. What posts have stuck with them? What do they come to you for? Sometimes we can’t see our own strengths until someone reflects them back.
Once you recognize your type, lean into it—then slowly borrow techniques from the others. A builder can add a strategist’s system. A storyteller can adopt a curator’s rhythm.
That’s where creative maturity lives: not in switching lanes, but in layering your approach with intention.
Because ultimately, blogging isn’t just about sharing ideas—it’s about understanding the lens you see the world through.
And once you get clear on that, everything else—voice, strategy, consistency—starts to align.
