10 signs someone is deeply attracted to you but trying to play it cool

There’s a thin line between casual interest and deep attraction, especially when someone’s trying to play it cool.

It’s like a secret game of hide and seek – they’re hiding their feelings, and you’re seeking signs of their attraction.

Decoding these signs can be tricky, but don’t worry, I’ve got your back. I’m here to help you catch those subtle hints that scream, “I’m into you!” without them actually saying it.

Here, we’ll explore ten signs that someone is deeply attracted to you but doing their best to keep it under wraps.

Let’s get started.

1) They’re always around

Ever noticed how they just ‘happen’ to be everywhere you are? It’s like they have a sixth sense about your whereabouts.

But here’s the thing, it’s not a coincidence or magic. It’s attraction, plain and simple.

People who are deeply attracted to you will find ways to be around you – at the coffee shop you frequent, the gym you workout at, or even the supermarket where you buy groceries. They’re subtly investing their time in you, even if they’re acting nonchalant about it.

When you spot them ‘randomly’ being in the same place as you, know that it might not be so random after all. This is a classic sign of someone who’s into you but is trying to keep their cool.

But remember, context matters. It’s essential to differentiate between someone genuinely being around because of shared interests or routines and someone crossing boundaries or making you uncomfortable. Always trust your instincts.

2) Their body language gives them away

Body language speaks volumes, often louder than words. And it’s something that’s incredibly hard to control, even when someone’s trying to play it cool.

Take this personal story of mine, for instance. There was this guy in college who always acted cool and detached around me. But his body language told a different story.

Every time we were in the same room, he’d unconsciously mirror my actions. If I crossed my legs, he’d do the same. When I leaned back, he’d follow suit. It was like an unplanned dance, mirroring each other’s moves.

And then there were his eyes. Even when we were in a group, I often caught him looking at me. His eyes would light up whenever our eyes met, and he’d quickly look away.

These subtle actions were signs of deep attraction that he couldn’t hide no matter how hard he tried to play it cool.

3) They remember the little things

Did you know that when someone is deeply attracted to you, your words and actions become etched in their memory?

It’s true. This is because when we’re attracted to someone, our brains release hormones like dopamine and oxytocin, which heighten our focus and attention towards that person.

So if they remember that offhand comment you made about your favorite childhood book, or they bring up that funny story you shared weeks ago, it’s a clear sign. They’re not just paying attention to you; they’re soaking up every detail.

This kind of recall isn’t usual in everyday interactions. It’s a sign of deep attraction. They’re trying to connect with you on a deeper level, even as they play it cool.

So the next time they mention something seemingly insignificant that you shared a while ago, take note. They’re more into you than they’re letting on.

4) They tease you in a playful way

There’s a reason why we associate teasing with playground crushes. No matter how old we get, playful teasing remains a universal sign of attraction.

If they’re constantly teasing you in a light-hearted, fun manner – not the mean-spirited or hurtful kind – it’s usually a sign they’re attracted to you. They’re trying to create a bond, establish rapport, and keep the conversation lively and engaging.

Remember, this isn’t about making fun of you or putting you down. It’s about sharing a laugh and creating shared jokes that only the two of you understand.

So the next time they playfully tease you about your coffee addiction or your terrible sense of direction, don’t be quick to dismiss it. It’s a classic sign that they’re attracted to you but trying to keep things casual and cool.

5) They initiate contact

Who’s the first one to text or call? If it’s usually them, that’s a clear sign of their interest in you.

People who are attracted to someone will find reasons to reach out. It could be sharing a funny meme, asking a random question, or just checking in to see how your day is going. The point is, they’re taking the initiative to engage with you.

This holds true even in a group setting. If they’re the one usually initiating conversations or making plans, chances are they’re into you.

The key here is consistency. We all reach out to others now and then. But if they’re consistently making the first move, they’re likely interested but trying to play it cool.

6) They show genuine concern for you

One of the most beautiful signs of deep attraction is genuine concern. When someone cares about your well-being, it speaks volumes about their feelings for you.

Are they the first one to ask if you’re okay when you’re feeling down? Do they show concern about your stressful day at work or an issue you’re dealing with? If so, it’s because your happiness matters to them.

They might try to play it cool, but this kind of care and concern isn’t something that can be faked. It comes from a place of deep affection and attraction.

See Also

So if they’re showing genuine concern for your well-being, take it as a sign. They’re deeply attracted to you, even if they’re trying to keep their feelings under wraps.

7) They open up to you

I remember this one time when a close friend of mine confessed that she had feelings for a guy in our circle. She hadn’t outright expressed her feelings to him yet, but she had started sharing more personal aspects of her life with him. She would talk about her dreams, fears, and even her insecurities.

Turns out, opening up to someone is a powerful sign of deep attraction. When someone shares their inner world with you, it’s a clear sign they trust you and feel comfortable around you.

If they start sharing personal stories or discussing deeper topics with you, it’s likely because they’re attracted to you. They’re subtly inviting you into their world, even if they’re outwardly playing it cool.

Pay attention to the conversations. If they’re getting deeper and more personal, it’s a clear sign of deep attraction.

8) They’re comfortable with silence

Silence doesn’t always mean discomfort or disinterest. In fact, being comfortable in silence with someone is a clear sign of deep attraction.

When someone is truly into you, they don’t feel the need to fill every moment with chatter. They’re perfectly content just being in your presence, enjoying the quiet moments together. It’s about quality, not quantity.

When there’s a pause in the conversation and they seem perfectly at ease, don’t panic. It’s not a sign that they’re bored or uninterested. Quite the opposite, it’s a sign that they’re deeply attracted to you but trying to keep it cool.

9) They give you meaningful compliments

Compliments are usually a clear sign of attraction. But when someone’s trying to play it cool, they won’t shower you with obvious flattery. Instead, they’ll give you meaningful compliments that show they really see you.

They might compliment your sense of humor, your intelligence, your creativity, or something else that goes beyond just your physical appearance. These compliments show that they appreciate who you are as a person.

If they’re giving you compliments that make you feel seen and appreciated for who you are, take note. It’s a sign of deep attraction, even if they’re trying to keep their feelings under wraps.

10) They make an effort to know your loved ones

The people we love and care for hold a special place in our hearts. So, when someone makes an effort to know them, it’s a pretty big deal.

If they’re showing genuine interest in your friends or family members, asking about them, or even making an effort to spend time with them, it’s an undeniable sign of deep attraction. They’re not just interested in you but in your world as well.

This level of interest is a clear indicator that they see you as more than just a casual acquaintance. They’re deeply attracted to you, even if they’re trying their best to play it cool.

 

Do you truly know yourself?

Your FREE personalized Moon Reading explores the secret depths of your personality, relationships and true purpose in life.

Get Your Free Reading

Picture of Tina Fey

Tina Fey

I've ridden the rails, gone off track and lost my train of thought. I'm writing to try and find it again. Hope you enjoy the journey with me.

RECENT ARTICLES

TRENDING AROUND THE WEB

4 zodiac signs you can rely on to keep a secret

4 zodiac signs you can rely on to keep a secret

Parent From Heart

8 phrases unhappy people regularly use without realizing it, says psychology

8 phrases unhappy people regularly use without realizing it, says psychology

Global English Editing

The art of slow living: 8 habits for a calmer, more intentional life

The art of slow living: 8 habits for a calmer, more intentional life

Hack Spirit

7 small things insecure people tend to take personally, according to psychology

7 small things insecure people tend to take personally, according to psychology

Hack Spirit

4 zodiac signs who find happiness in solitude (and why they prefer being alone)

4 zodiac signs who find happiness in solitude (and why they prefer being alone)

Parent From Heart

9 signs someone has an exceptionally kind heart, according to psychology

9 signs someone has an exceptionally kind heart, according to psychology

Small Business Bonfire